Florida resident Aaron Stahl was arrested and charged with voyeurism, a third-degree according to Florida Statutes. The victim was in a store when she allegedly noticed Stahl crouched with a device at the end of an extended arm. Stahl was later by law enforcement using the getaway vehicle used in the in the store surveillance camera.
Caught Red-handed
The footage confirms that the assailant was indeed holding an illuminated device with his hand moving towards the victim’s skirt, and upon discovery, ran towards the vehicle registered under his name. Law enforcement was able to pull his license and photograph and was taken into custody. There was no mobile phone found on this person during the arrest but was later retrieved in his location and was described to be an iPhone 5.
Stahl initially provided consent for the phone to be search but later on retracted which prompted law enforcement to pursue a search warrant for PIN which was later on denied due to a possible Fifth Amendment violation.
The Fifth Amendment is the bill that protects the accused to testify or further incriminate themselves in court proceedings. Invoking the bill provides the witness the privilege to decline.
Compelling the Suspect
Faced with a roadblock. Law enforcements could in theory attempt the 10,000 possible combinations that will unlock the device, but risk the built in safety feature that will completely wipe the phone after more than ten times incorrect attempts. The phone manufacturer claims that they are unable to provide such a personally sensitive information because they are not stored in any database but on the phone alone. Since the assailant is alive and in their custody, the state could only compel the suspect to produce the passcode which Stahl refused to.
The three-panel judge ruled against the responde nt and quashed his motion to withhold the passcode that may unlock the mobile phone that may contain evidence of his crime. Judge Black further explains that the case is about surrender and not of testimony, and the state has provided the unquestionably reasonable particularity of Stahl’s knowledge of the passcode and its self-authenticating nature. Furthermore, the court recognizes law enforcements processes when it comes to criminal cases where this has always played a part.
Passcodes and Fingerprint-based Locks
This decision was made through the separation between passcodes and the use of fingerprint-based locks. Unlocking the phone using the built-in scanner is not considered as “communicate knowledge” similar to proving the combination to a complex strongbox, but it is much more similar to surrendering samples like fingerprints, voice, and handwriting samples. This was also not a debate if the smartphone does possess images and videos, the state argued that unlocking the phone is not the same as providing the photos and videos that might contain evidence of the case against him, but will allow the state to pursue further the investigation that may incriminate the suspect or eliminate from the list of accused.
“We are not inclined to believe that the Fifth Amendment should provide greater protection to individuals who passcode protect their iPhones with letter and number combinations than to individuals who use their fingerprint as the passcode,” the opinion continues. “Compelling an individual to place his finger on the iPhone would not be a protected act; it would be an exhibition of a physical characteristic, the forced production of physical evidence, not unlike being compelled to provide a blood sample or provide a handwriting exemplar.” (n.d.). Retrieved from https://consumerist.com/2016/12/13/court-rules-that-police-can-force-you-to-tell-them-your-phones-passcode.
Moving Forward
Through the quick technological advancement, Florida Law Enforcement officers may now ask suspected perpetrators to unlock their devices that have scanners. This is has been set apart from what the Fifth Amendment protects and could be compelled by the state.
The difference between the passcode and fingerprint-based locks as applied to law proceedings is expected to be heavily fought in court. The Florida court case is expected to be used as a precedent in making this applicable in other States. There is, however, a fine distinction in the case of Stahl.
Stahl was apprehended for a third-degree offense of using his cellphone as a voyeur. It is almost like saying that the cellphone is not just a repository for the images, it was also the instrument of the crime. This is like shooting a gun to see the bullet striations. To put it in another way, if the images were not of the woman in the store, she would not have any legal basis to file a complaint.
Cellphone as Evidence
The use of the cell phone is relatively narrow and asking for the passcode might not be applicable in other cases. It was expected that the cell phone would not have been used to incriminate the suspect. It just so happens that it was not also the only way for him to prove his innocence. It was already determined that the cell phone was owned by the suspect. There was no more need to prove otherwise as it was in his custody when he was apprehended.
Like all new technologies, the courts have to adjust with how the spirit of the law was intended to be implemented. There is always the danger of self-incrimination. It is also the reason why suspects are advised not to represent themselves in a court of law.
As the use of technology or the introduction of new technology causes changes in how things are done, there would also be adjustments in how the law would interpret some things. For instance, the use of video as evidence was long held to be controversial. However, increasingly, more and more people use dashcams and action cameras in court during trials.
This is not going to be the last time that we will hear about the Florida. This is just the beginning of more decisions about technology in court.

