Beware the no-name 2TB Flash Drives on Sale

There was a recent announcement that Kingston would release a 2 TB flash drive. The day of the release came and went, and all the stocks were sold out. That was Kingston placing a portable storage device with a massive capacity in the hands of consumers. However, if you have been closely paying attention to sales on eBay as well as on other sites, you would have noticed that there are a lot of sellers of 2 TB USB flash drives. The problem is that these are all fake.

These fake USB flash drives are actual flash drives and your computer that it has 2 TB of storage space. However, the moment you copy files to the drives, you would end up with files with 0 file size. The flash drive reports that it has 2 TB even though it does not have them.

Hard Disks and Flash Drives

It is important to remember that a flash drive, or a solid-state drive for that matter, which includes SD cards, and other kinds of memory cards are built differently from hard disks. A hard disk has a directory or file where the drive contents are stored. Every time that the free space is requested, this file is read, and the operating system or the file system does the math. The disk also contains other information in a system area. This includes the number of platters, sectors, and clusters, as well as the bad sector blocks for a particular partition.

This data is practically re-written every time that the hard disk is partitioned. Every time that the disk is checked for bad sectors, this information is also stored in the hard disk. Hard disks are also larger than their actual stated size. Whenever a new bad sector is found, it is marked as unusable, and a corresponding amount of good sectors are re-allocated from the free unused area. The information gathering is dynamic, and the user can reallocate as he needs.

On a solid state memory device, the analogy is still used, with clusters and sectors. However, because these data areas have a fixed number of write/rewrite times, there is also an internal database which counts how many times a sector has been used. Called “wear-leveling” this is a method which keeps track of the number of times a sector has been written to. If and when the usable number is reached, the sector will be tagged and no more write cycles will be allowed in that particular area. Any information on that sector will be saved to a safe area.

Solid state drives have a different read/write cycles before a sector is retired. However, these drives can have a lifetime of anywhere from a few months and up to ten years.

Prior Information

One other difference between a solid state drive and a hard disk is that the nature of the wear-leveling means that the drive has to know how many sectors it has. This number would not change even if you partition the hard disk to smaller chunks of data storage. This prior information is used to create fake flash drives. The read only system information is marked to have a capacity of 2 TB (or 1 TB, as there are some fake drives with 1 TB). The same information is used in the wear-leveling database of sectors. That database is full of non-existent sectors.

When you write information to the solid state drive, it writes to individual sectors and records the information in a table for wear-leveling information. Unfortunately, with missing or non-existent sectors, the data being written goes nowhere.

Partition and Format

Going deeper into the issue, you can try to repartition the flash drive. At some point, the partitioning will yield an error message that the operation failed. Trying to find the areas with usable storage, you can have the partition and repartition. Continuing to do so until you end up with a partition which is composed of only the real working sectors.

We got our hands on a fake 2TB flash drive and tried to repartition until we can get to a small slice which contains sectors which all work. Using GParted which is a Linux program, we created smaller and smaller partitions until we were able to completely write over all the sectors without any missing data. We ended up with a small 16GB sector.

Partitioning and repartitioning to smaller and smaller storage takes time. However, there is an alternative. You can run a low-level format of the flash drive. This will also mark bad sectors, including imaginary sectors, as bad. However, this may take a long time to scan for a 2TB flash drive.

From the above exercise, it seems that the fake flash drives were made by a no-name manufacturer and then the flash information was encoded to read 2TB. Whenever you write a file to the drive, it will still write the file. However, the directory information will show that a lot of the files you wrote to the drive are 0 bytes in size.

As early as 2014, there were already reports of fake 2TB drives. This is especially true of eBay. However, eBay has not been successful in delisting fake drives from sale on their site. Kingston has only recently released true 2TB drives, and even though they were very expensive, the merchandise was still lapped up by consumers.

When buying flash drives or microSD cards, look for a well-known brand, as well as a reputable online vendor. UnlimitedCellular.com sells certified original microSD cards which are designed to give you a long time of use.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Comment Should not be empty