Online security is a serious business. That is why many brands claim that they offer the best security there is, which helps boost the brand’s reputation. But due to various claims, knowing the truth can only be done by an outside expert. One who provides the best security can only be revealed after a series of tests and audits.
With this, Wire, a messaging app, offers a new feature that enables users to conduct an external audit of its encryption protocol, Proteus. The said the external audit is also extended to various protocols in different apps. However, the audit comes with a fee, especially that it was conducted by Jean-Philippe Aumasson and Markus Vervier of Kudelski Security and X41 D-Sec respectively, it gives value to the users. The external audit will likewise provide users an objective analysis on what brand holds the best security.
But what real value does the external audit do? Aside from giving users an objective review on what WIRE’s Proteus can do, the audit also helps the brand shed some light on the recent criticism it recently received after a blog post gained heavy attention online, especially catching the eye of the security community. And since the post was shared on Twitter where it gained more social media hype, Wire rejected the criticisms with an argument that the company was unjustly targeted by anonymous social media accounts.
The critical blog post was published in Medium about the implementation of Proteus across all platforms of Wire, including Android, iOS, Windows, MacOS, Linux. Proteus was also implemented in Wire for The Web which is a browser-based implementation using webRTC.
Wire rejected the criticisms. It argued that it was unfair being targeted by anonymous social media accounts posting online. To hear the other side of the coin, TechCrunch tried to get in touch with the author named Tina Membe about her critical post in Medium. However, the author refused to reveal his or her true identity, but qualifying himself or herself as not a security expert.
Despite the disclaimer, which can certainly cast doubts on the validity of the review, the author still stood by the article that the security code of Wire was not secure. The criticism was also extended to Wire’s certificate pinning, which according to the author was flawed since it can be allegedly bypassed by top online attackers.
In theory, only security experts or security researchers would know about these things. However, it does not stop a normal person, even a non-technical person, to write about possible vulnerabilities. It may not be part of his job. However, it helps the company to pinpoint the possible source of error in implementation. Individuals and tech bloggers like these do not earn from their efforts, although sometimes they are also scrutinized for any possible reason for gain or profit.
Online messaging security, especially in an end-to-end application is a serious matter. An end-to-end encryption means that the message is encrypted at the source, and then decrypted at the recipient. There may be a copy of it somewhere on the server. However, that is also encrypted. The only method for it to be decrypted is when it reaches the correct recipient. This end-to-end encryption is done with crypto keys.
There were issues revolving around a bug which allows the use of invalid public keys being processed and transmitted. These should be tagged as an error. However, experts still considered Proteus as high-security encryption due to its state-of-the-art algorithms and cryptographic protocols. Accordingly, the software engineering methods and practices also help lower the risk of errors.
For the most part, well-documented methods and practices follow ISO class inspections. This makes the testing and compliance easier to follow. These practices are also meant to ensure that the company follows international industry standards regarding security protocols in the workplace.
More so, the review included the protocol specification and implementation of Proteus messaging protocol, Cryptobox API, and C wrapper Cryptobox-C, which were described as a simple yet high-level API. Furthermore, the scope of the review also covered CoffeeScript and crypto box.
Although the reviews of the external auditors are looking pretty promising for Wire, the third layer of security review is well under way. Hence, we could still expect from meaty and insightful information on how Wire’s security standing fairs.
What is unique about the situation is that, in general, messaging apps do not merit this high level of scrutiny. However, because they are used to send a large volume of data, messaging apps like Viber, Snapchat, WhatsApp, Hangouts, Facebook Messenger, Kik, and others should do external audits on a regular basis. It is expected that they do practice external auditing, without the need of the public knowing.
With an independent third-party doing the external audit, it allows the company to see their security from a possible source of risk. In general, an external audit entailed a rundown of the best practices and judged according to documentation and code. It is seldom a black box type of audit, where the auditors run tests without looking at the code. White box testing tests the code against the possible sources of errors or attacks. Unfortunately, with white box testing, the only things you can test are those sources of error or security risks which are already well-known or have been documented elsewhere. The unknown is not tested against the app.
The external auditor’s summation of the audit or review as follows:
- Wire’s components show high security due to state-of-the-art algorithms, cryptographic protocols, and software engineering practices.
- There were some issues found, but none of them was critical to affecting security.
And for the issues, Wire already deployed its team to fix the problems affecting iOS, Android, and Wire for the web and its desktop apps
