We have all gone to apply for one document, credential or related particulars in the past and found out that by the time we got there the required documents we must have taken to such offices won’t be accepted due to one reason or the other. Sadly , we would just have to go back and get the one needed for easy facilitation of such processes (or dump it if what you were applying for was not worth it in the first place). It seems that now, not only human attendants would reject your documents in the kind of scenario created above but even a robot would, and don’t be surprised when the reason you get beats the sunrise out of you.
This was the case of a Taiwanese man living in New Zealand who wanted to get his passport renewed but was rejected by the online facial recognition robot because it thought that his eyes were closed. In what caused an uproar on social media, the DJ who goes by the name of Richard Lee, was in the process of renewing his passport so that he would be able to spend time with his family during the holidays back in Taiwan, but was surprised when it continually turned down his picture and claimed that his eyes were closed. Reportedly, he called into the Department of Internal Affairs in the country and when he was asked to submit even more pictures, he did so but all to no avail. It was not until he went out to get his pictures taken afresh that he had some luck and even then, only one of the bunch was accepted.
It is no news that different races in different parts of the world have distinct facial features with which one can easily distinguish them from the other and small eyes being one of those peculiar to the Asians, it is a big surprise why this kind of parameter would not have been built into the intelligence technology in the first place. For a start, the agency themselves should have considered the option that they would be attending to various nationalities from different parts of the world and should, therefore, prepare their system to be able to draw needed data irrespective of race. Despite the Internal Affairs department of New Zealand claiming that this was one of the most advanced pieces of technology run in the whole world, Lee fails to agree with this mindset and we are sure that a lot of people are with him on this one too.
Going ahead to post the occurrence on his social media accounts, Lee got a lot of comments and suggestions from users with the majority of them believing that the AI is racist and some even encouraging the DJ to press charges. However, Lee himself has maintained a calm outlook on the matter and stated that he didn’t feel racially abused in any way, crediting the fault to the inadequacy of the robot and not just some sick joke to play pranks on Asians like him. According to the DJ, he has had small eyes since his birth and found it surprising when the system initially hit him with the ‘allegation’ of his eyes being closed even though they were as widely opened as can be. Speaking with Reuters, the engineering student cum DJ said: “No hard feelings on my part, I’ve always had very small eyes and facial recognition technology is relatively new and unsophisticated.” (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.yahoo.com/tech/zealand-passport-robot-tells-applicant-asian-descent-open-084812732.html
The above just goes on to describe the limitations that we can start to suffer if we decide to entrust all of our work to Artificial Intelligence without at least, a small section of Human Intelligence dedicated to guiding it . While this kind of bias cannot be avoided in the long run, it should be noted that the system is not entirely at fault here but a culmination of factors that would have accrued over time. One of the prime things to consider is that the algorithm was developed by humans, not the AI itself, and there are therefore bound to be some bias in the system based on the code developer. AI is also a system that constantly learns and bases most of its work on data that it gets from a region. Being in the New Zealand area, it can be understood that it is to used to interpreting special cases of data like the Asian man’s face proposed so even if that was a major shortcoming, it could not have been addressed by the developers earlier. These and many more stand on the list of limitations that the AI technology has and shows that it is not unbiased.
At the end of it all, Lee was finally able to get his passport renewed as one of the pictures he submitted was finally accepted, meaning he would be reunited with his family again this Christmas season even though a software could have prevented that. To further make light of the matter, he posted another picture of himself on his Snapchat account where he cartooned his eyes to be real wide and accompanied it with a caption “I hope they accept this one. Wish me luck.”
The Internal Affairs Department of New Zealand were let off easy this time around and with another person, they could be eating lawsuits for breakfast on all the days of Christmas.